Showing posts with label Teacher Talk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Teacher Talk. Show all posts

Sunday, October 25, 2015

Making Dialogue Punctuation Tactile

 

 

Texas TEKS Student Expectation for Fifth Grade


5.16.A.iii: Write imaginative stories that include dialogue that develop the story

The Challenge


It's difficult for my ELL's (English Language Learners) to fully grasp punctuation rules. We drop the inverted question marks and exclamation marks when they change languages, and so much of their cognitive power translating and functioning in a second language. (Something I feel equivalently anytime I step into a room of native Spanish speakers and I'm the only non-native speaker there.)

So, the challenge is that I want my fifth graders to be able to write imaginative, inventive stories, and dialogue, I know as a reader and a write, is massively important to creating engaging narrative, regardless of the level or age of the author.

The Process


Lesson 1:

Part I. I downloaded the declarative knowledge of what the word dialogue means and what it look like through abbreviate notes. (Also played a Brainpop video to one group for reinforcement)

Lesson 2

Part I: Brief verbal review of notes with emphasis on noticing punctuation marks.

Part II: Students copied examples of dialogue out on sentence strips. Then, I asked them to make a cut between the dialogue and the dialogue tag. After this, I asked them to cut off the comma, then the quotation marks, and finally the punctuation. I modeled with my own sentence how I could rearrange all the pieces to move the dialogue tag to the front almost like a magic trick. The students then tried to replicate the effect with their own manipulatives and I helped them. (Sometimes we had to make an extra comma or extra period, depending on the sentence.) Finally, students put their pieces into baggies and mixed the pieces up and challenged friends to reconstruct their sentences correct. For extra challenge, some cut the entire sentence into separate words as well. They loved the challenge.


Lesson 3

Part I: Whiteboards: Reviewed parts of dialogue and dialogue tags by showing sentences with no punctuation whatsoever and have students identify using the context only which part was dialogue and which part was tag. Whiteboards let me give immediate feedback.

Part II: Adding punctuation on whiteboards--students then started adding in correct punctuation on their own, but easily fixed with rapid teacher feedback.

Part III: Students used map colors to add in commas, question marks, exclamation marks, periods and quotation marks onto worksheets with prewritten dialogues.

Lesson 4: Scaffolded Dialogue Construction

We read part of an amazing wordless graphic novel by Shaun Tan called The Arrival.

Part I. The book is about an immigrant man passing through a surreal version of New York and adapting to life there.

Using whiteboards, we invented our own dialogue for the page, discussing and making inferences about what we think the characters might be talking about.

Again, using whiteboards at this point in the process helps me correct errors in the students' understanding of how to compose dialogue very, very quickly. This is very much "You do--I help" part of the guided release model.







Part II. Once students start so show proficiency, we moved to writing on notebook paper and practicing making correct indentations when we change characters. We also practiced the importance of paying attention to neatness and organization (skipping first line, pausing at the pink line and returning to the red line on standard notebook paper). We discussed as a class when we should or should not start new paragraphs.

If you don't own this book, it's totally worth having in your library. It does an amazing job of making you feel like an immigrant in a foreign country while using dream-like imagery to provoke deep questions and thoughts--all without a single word in the entire book.This was still guided work, but with less support.

The next step is for students to compose the next set of dialogue on their own! More to come!



End Product Goal: Social Studies Integrated Project: Loyalist vs. Patriot Dialogues! [Coming soon!]





Sunday, October 18, 2015

Unit 2: Exploration & Colonization Part II

This project idea isn't my idea, so I've got to give credit where credit is due. I got the idea from this blogger after stumbling onto her stuff via Pinterest.


I don't know what her demographics are or what her kids' levels look like, but I wanted to scaffold my students' work a little more in order for them to have success on this project. 

First, I made a bad example and a good example of the project. I had them pass them around and talk in groups about what a good project looks like and what the bad project looked like and how to fix it.





Also, rather than have them Google information, we used this website:


I also gave them a similar research sheet, but I wanted them to practice citing their sources, so I gave them a column for sources, although mostly their information all came from the same website. 

The students' learned about and presented information on their colonies and it stuck well enough that I had one confide to me he knew the answers on a district test four weeks later because he had found out that information while researching his colony. 

Next year, I intend to repeat the project, but I will tweak it to encourage the kids to take the map parts home and include more color. They look great, but I think the originals from Room 6's are a little more aesthetically pleasing.

Even so, for a first six weeks project that included research before the scope and sequence calls for teaching the research process, it turned out great.



Social Studies & Reading Integration


Since nonfiction passages have the highest Lexile levels on the STAAR test, my grade level set a goal to work more on nonfiction throughout the year to help raise students' ability to comprehend nonfiction and to integrate more Science into the Reading classroom.

During the first six weeks, I took pieces of Teacher Created Materials digital books on the 13 Colonies and broke it up into small chunks. I then paired the students off and had them read through their chunk and break it down. 

To build their comprehension, we practiced Repeated (Close) Reading:

  1. Read the section for yourself silently
  2. Read it again with your partner and talk about it
  3. Read it a third time and work on the Figure 19 skill assigned
  4. Read it a fourth time and break out the main idea for each paragraph
The students did this in pairs and made posters on large sheets and then presented/taught their information to the rest of the class. This is a very time-costly process, but the deep reading really produces growth.



Social Studies & Fluency


We also built reading fluency by performing two plays about the colonists. 

We used this book:


I looked it up on Amazon and only two people have bothered to review, and one of them was scathing and rather hateful. So to be fair, if you go looking for this book, it says it's easy to read and it it is definitely that. If you teach in a school with students on fifth grade level, you may find the readability far below what you're looking for. However, if you work with ESL, bilingual, or struggling readers, these plays can be very empowering. Know your students. Mine ate it up! We hosted multiple performances throughout the day. Talk about reading with purpose. Performance is a great purpose for reading!


Sunday, September 27, 2015

The Big Data Derailment


Let me start this article off on the right foot:

I do like data.

I really do.

Not as much as a Triple Chocolate Andy's Frozen Custard, but I do like it. I sit around at home with cat and play with data for fun. (Frozen custard on the side would make it even better)

Now that I've admitted that I'm going to say something bold. Something that might make you curl your toes a little bit because it (along with some of my other views on literacy) go against the current of what's popular in testing, er, teaching these days.

Analyzing STAAR data is derailing literacy instruction in Texas.


Data Driven to Death


Data is good, but it's only good if you know how to read it, and the longer I watch trends of analysis the more I see data being completely misinterpreted all over. 

We're missing the forest for the trees, folks.

Like I mentioned in a previous article, Reading isn't like the other tests. Reading tests have two components: passages and questions.

If you're only analyzing the questions and using that to draw conclusions about quality of instruction, student ability, and overall literacy and direction of you or your school's direction, then you could be sending your train out the front window.

Why are so many schools struggling so much to catch up to current Reading standards and failing. There's a lot of reasons, because an entire state of people and schools is so vast and diverse, but I'd like to focus on just one aspect today: miscalculations.

Teachers and administrators are reading their SE hotspots correctly and even putting them into perspective by using blueprints and testing frequency charts. However, with this advent of testing culture and the need for everyone to be 'data driven' all the time, it has taught districts, schools, and teachers to think about literacy like this:


We study and study and study. We discuss and discuss and discuss. We plan and plan and plan. We do it all for the sake of being data driven! We want to fix those particular SE's! We must! We're doing it for our kids' sakes, our schools' sakes, our own sakes!

But it's not working.

If it were the real answer, for all the work we're putting in over four years worth of STAAR now, we ought to be seeing more results. Instead, more schools than ever are being classified by the state as "Improvement Required."

Why, oh, why?

Because, like I mentioned, we're missing the forest for the trees. Because of popular trends in educational jargon, we've focused on the tiles, the small pieces of what we think the problem is based on what a testing company paid by the state (and now fired by the state) told us our problem was.

But here's the thing.

The tiles aren't literacy. They're good for analysis to an extent, but they're not enough.

Why? Because literacy isn't tiles. It isn't isolated concepts or isolated skills. All those little things: character roles, conflict, main idea, inferencing, drawing conclusions, context clues--they all link up into what literacy actually is. If we want to improve, we have to zoom out to the big picture.

Literacy is a mosaic of cognitive skills. 



Those skills that the test doesn't open examine or quantify are what break our students if we don't address them in the classroom, even if we don't have numerical data from a test to quantify or justify their instruction. 

If you have a population of students who are not passing STAAR, don't only look at your SE's.

Also consider: 
  • Metacognition (Rigor): Can your students think about thinking?
  • Lexile/Guided Reading Levels: Can your students understand enough of the passage to have a chance of passing?
  • Do your students believe in themselves? Do they think they can be good readers?
  • Fluency: Do your students read fast enough to remember what they read?
  • Decoding: Hand in hand with fluency--Do your students need serious intervention?
  • Vocabulary: Do your students know what to do when they don't understand?
  • Background Knowledge: What are you doing to broaden the knowledge base of students whose families can't afford to take them places to gain new experiences?
  • Language Transition: What SIOP strategies are you using to help students find success in their second language?
  • Stamina: Are you giving your students time every day to read self-selected texts? Reading is a skill, not a content. You don't get better at doing it by learning about it.




Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Unit 2: Exploration and Colonization

Day 1


We began by adding a new tab: Exploration & Colonization and making our big idea page. We drew a ship to represent the many people traveling to the New World via ship and asked the Big Question: Why do people leave their country and where do they go?

I don't feel this one is as profound as my unit one question, so maybe I can revise it next year, but it's still an important question.








In order to talk about the movement of so many people, kids need to be able to visualize the world. Many fifth graders don't come preloaded with that knowledge, so I break out my hoard of 5 classroom globes, and we hunt down the names of the continents and label this simple map.

Then we make a map key coloring the two continents we're focusing on: North American and Europe.

We add symbols to England and the colonies.

We mark an X for San Augustine later, during the San Augustine mini-lesson.





Day 2


Texas history TEKS call for history to begin at the founding of St. Augustine, so I copied off on white paper a sketch of San Augustine and used map colors to colorize in no more than 30 seconds of furious scribbling.

The picture flaps open, and the content inside reads:


  • owned by Spain
  • fort
  • in Florida
  • missionaries





Day 3


Next, I use cards that have pictures of famous colonists or explorers. I put the pictures on cardstock and wrote very brief notes on each person. I hung two signs in the room: Conqueror/ Colonizer.

I gave the students the notes on how to tell the difference (also conquerors come first) and as I displayed each leader's name, the students thought about it, then walked to the sign they thought the person best fit. 

I also asked students to put a star next to the reason they thought would most likely convince them to leave home. Hadn't I run out of time, I would have had them write about this, but c'est la vie.


Day 4


I show parts of a clip of America the Story of Us, Episode 1. The entire documentary is too long, and you need to be careful to cut if off before they go into the details of the people of Jamestown resorting to cannibalism. If you splice the video right, the children can still a recreation of life in Jamestown and what their economy looked like. 

We made notes in the shape of Jamestown. I like to have all the kids stand and count off how many would be dead if we were there. 





Day 5


I showed another segment of America, the Story of Us, showing the struggles of the Pilgrims and the harshness of their climate. We drew our notes in the shape of the Mayflower.















Day 6



Students took home this trunk and drew three non-electronic devices they would take with them if they went packing to the New World with the Pilgrims.

The picture is from a book called History Pockets: Life in Plymouth which you can get on Amazon.










Day 7


We add flaps of two important aspects of colonial government: Mayflower Compact & Virginia House of Burgesses (or House of Burgers or Boogers, according to some of my more humorous children).

The inside of the Mayflower Compact says it is a form of democracy because the people on board all agreed to obey the rules, which they wrote themselves.

The inside of Virginia House of Burgesses says it was the first representative government because the men were elected by the people to make decisions for the good of the colony.







Day 8



I divided the class into groups to study the 3 regions of the colonies. Using Teacher Created Materials as adopted by our district, the students read articles and practiced Reading Fix-Up strategies while pulling the main ideas out onto a large sheet of paper in groups. This took an entire class period to do with me walking around and scaffolding, but the students worked very hard and were very meticulous in their work. Then each group presented their findings, and we colored in the regions of the colonies. We added the economies of each region by invent a map key.






Day 9


We studied conventions of a friendly letter in Language Arts, and then analyzed this letter on Scholastic with audio:


Using ideas from here, I scaffolded a letter for my students by brainstorming with them and provided sentence stems. (Remember, I teach bilingual.) For a monolingual classroom, you might use fewer stems. If students have their own ideas or want to add more, go for it!

[to be continued!]



Sunday, August 30, 2015

Independent vs. Interactive Reading Models



Marshmallowing It


Reading is Reading is Reading.

Isn't it?

No, not really.

I remember back in the day (90's, whut, whut!?) we had homeroom or AR periods where we got a luscious 20-30 minutes to do nothing but read. As a teacher I know now that one of our untested standards in the TEKS is for students to read independently for 'sustained' periods of time.

I tried this years ago as a fledgling Reading teacher and was disappointed at the common struggles teachers face with in class independent reading.

  • Wigglers
  • Frequent Flyers "getting a tissue"
  • Book-Lookers
  • Page Starers
  • Noise Boys

All in all, I felt like I was losing more time than I was making and that could have been used for the unending number of standards I needed to be addressing. The second year that I tried it, I tried to do small group fluency at the same time, but inevitably the children were more interested in me whispering advice and modeling to a small group than they were in their books. Sad, right?



So what was going on? Why didn't it work that well? It was okay, but it wasn't great. And I don't know about you, but my class needs great, not good, if we're to make our goals.

Making the StayPuff


So this last year I tried a thing. Most things I've learned to do effectively have come from a random question popping into my head and then trying out different techniques to play with all the variables in the classroom.

The thing was, "How can I know whether my students are reading their books to completion rather than abandoning them?"

Tradition and trainings all suggest Reading Logs, but frankly, who's got time for that?


My ESL students need every moment they're with me to be high-charged, effective activity, and simply copying out by hand titles and authors and pulling folders and putting them away is a terrible idea.

It's just a waste of time.

We live in an era where everything we do gets tracked for us automatically: how much we spend, where we spend it, what we watched on Netflix, when we bought something on Amazon, even how many steps we walked today

The age of logging things with a pen and paper by hand just to make a list died a long time ago.

So, what does this mean?

It means it's time to reinvent the Reading Log into something that's ALIVE.


How to Transition from Independent to Interactive Reading

  1. I make a spreadsheet with the kids loaded onto in the order that they sit in class. There are enough blank cells for one week per page.
  2. As students get out their library books, I walk around the room and note down 1-2 key words from the title. Then I note down the page they're beginning on for that day. 
  3. I give each child a sticky note for the day. 
  4. On the board I've posted a sentence stem concerning something that we've learned. For example, it might say, "On page _____, I found an example of imagery. The example is_________." 
  5. Students read their books looking for whatever is on the board and as they find them, I walk around looking at their notes. 
  6. As the week progresses, I change the stem, making it more challenging or simply different if I see a need to practice something. "On page _____, I found an example of imagery that appeals to my sense of __________________." "The most vivid imagery I found this week in my reading was ______________ because ____________________."
  7. I call the whole group to the floor. 
  8. I (or Ramon) read a novel on their level and I model the same sentence stem and discuss my book.
  9. Students share their findings with partners as I listen in.
  10. Students put their sticky notes into the Reading Logs, making their Reading Logs a meaningful collections of work. 

Advantages of Interactive Reading over Independent Reading


  • I know what my students are interested in because I look at their books every single day.
  • I know who's struggling on a book. If day to day the pages didn't increase much, there's a problem.
  • I know who goes home and reads a lot and who goes home and reads none or little. Shakira says hips don't lie, but I'm here to tell you that books don't lie, either.
  • The class is in a constant spiral review.
  • Reading Logs are meaningful work.
  • Students are accountable for content because of the sticky note and discussion.
  • Students want to remember more of what they read so they can talk about it with their classmates and me.
  • Students see me read and want to read what I'm reading.
  • Students read chapter books to completion.
  • Students ask me for book recommendations.
  • Students feel empowered.
  • Students build stamina for those lovely (ridiculously long) state assessments.
  • We build a classroom culture of reading.


Parent Reading Flyer

Parents want to help their students become better readers, but may not know exactly how. I've created a flyer with a few modern ideas of how parents can emphasize the importance of reading. You can download it for free at my TPT website.

Saturday, August 29, 2015

Favorite Fiction Mentor Texts

A mentor text is a book that a teacher uses repeatedly to illustrate different concepts. Already being familiar with the story itself means that students can focus on certain aspects of the story or reading strategies being applied to the story.

I'd like to share a few of my favorite mentor texts today for fifth grade appropriate fiction. These are all books that both I and my students love. According to my school librarian, I'm a "book snob" (I have standards!), so these are books that really had to impress me to make the cut as something I want to read and reread.

King Midas: Stewig/Rayyan


In fifth grade in Texas our special genre for our year is myths. Where fourth grade gets to introduce folktales and tall tales, fifth graders get to dip their toes into Greek/Roman and Norse mythologies for the first time in a school setting.

King Midas is a classic tale of king who loved gold too much, and this retelling of the story is a powerful one with a big dose of whimsy and humor. Fifth graders like details and the illustrations in this book tell the story so well that you can make inferences and draw conclusions just by inspecting all corners of the page with as much attention as if you were chasing down Waldo. 

The story provides many opportunities to talk about character traits and change. It also has heaps of foreshadowing if you look for the hidden pictures inside the pictures. 

The Selfish Giant: Oscar Wilde/Chris Beatrice


This story is a classic, and as much as I love "The Happy Prince", Wilde has a better narrative voice here and the 19th century world is easier for younger modern readers to understand than its other famous companion story. 

The story is amazing, and the illustrations by Beatrice are the most beautiful version I've ever seen in any store anywhere for this classic story. You can really dive into them and hunt out the meaning of the pictures to use practicing predictions and making connections. Beyond that, the symbolism at the end (spoiler: the giant dies) is very challenging and leave some students feeling a little confused though still intrigued. This is good. Some students will be ready to start understanding symbolism already, and others you can start down the path toward carving out those synaptic pathways in their brains. 

Also, it makes a good complement to King Midas because they share similar (though not equal) themes, and reading them both makes for an interesting compare/contrast discussion. 

The Summer My Father was Ten: Brisson


Last but not least, this book is a great example of realistic fiction. I like it because the kids make so many personal connections. Everyone's gotten carried away while playing and done something bad at some point in their childhood, and the lesson about forgiveness and friendship in this book is powerful and deep. 

The illustrations are also deep, just like my other favorite books, adding another layer to the story rather than just being pictures.

Students sometimes like to make the connection between the kids playing in Mr. Bellavista's garden to the children playing in the Selfish Giant's garden. Again, it's another book that really connects well for discussions when read in tandem with the others, even though they all represent different genres.


Finding the Books

While I happened to get two out of three of these books at a Half-Price books in Dallas, they're all available on Amazon in case you can't find them in your school or local library. They're worth owning. You won't regret. 

Sunday, August 23, 2015

STAAR and Lexile Levels

Higher Order Thinking vs. Basic Comprehension


There's been a trend since STAAR rolled out that we have to push our students hard with higher order thinking questions if we want them to be successful. The general message has also been that the SE's that have weak percentiles meant weak teaching.

I've begun to seriously doubt all of that.


Horse of a Different Color


Let's face it. The STAAR Reading test (and the subject matter itself) is not like Math, Science, or Writing at all. 

Not at all.

Why is that so? 

Because the Reading test isn't just questions. It's composed of questions and passages. Therefore, when reviewing data about how your students did on any given Reading test, you're only looking at part of the picture. 

But if you really want to accelerate your students' growth, you have to look at both pieces.


Passages


So how do we talk about the passages? How do we analyze them? I think many people in the education training field have neglected this because it wouldn't seem that you could turn the passages into any kind of data or anything concrete or predictable. Yes, TEA gives us some idea of how many genres might be represented per grade level and how many passages there will be, but other than that, what else is there to say? You can't predict the topic. Unlike Math or Science standards where you can guess pretty close what the test will look like, Reading has remained rather nebulous. In an attempt to predict STAAR and do something to foster growth, districts and professional development people have gone question-crazy.

But what Genie used to tell me on Saturday mornings is true:




Great minds don't think alike. Great minds think for themselves.






Thinking for Ourselves


What if I told you that Reading passages from STAAR do follow a pattern, a pattern concrete enough that you can accurately predict your students' progress and likely performance based on a single set of numbers that is easy to track and easy to explain to small children?

It took many, many hours of research, investigation, and questioning, but here's what I've discovered: if students' Lexile level matches that of the average of the test, the student will pass.

Not only that, but I've calculated the average Lexile trends of the last three years and you can see what they are for free by downloading them here:






Using this data, you can set concrete, measurable, frequent goals and formative assessments as long as you have access to a program that provides Lexile level reports like Istation does. 


Back to Godzilla & King Kong


So what is more important? What's more powerful? Higher order thinking questions or basic comprehension?

Neither.

Because it's not a fight.

Harder questions are not the goal. Harder questions are the conduit through which the assessment discovers whether or not the student was able to comprehend the passage fully.

So what's the goal? The goal should be comprehension. The tools to test that comprehension should be higher order questions because they most accurately weed out who got it and who didn't. 

Where are test strategies in all this?

Test strategies are how teachers and students try to compensate for the difference between a student's reading level and the level of the passage he/she has to read and answer about. This can help them score a few points, and for bubble kids, it could help push them over into passing, but it's not the ultimate answer.

The ultimate answer is higher comprehension.

Set yourself and your students up for success.

Set comprehension as your goal and watch your students take control and grow, grow, grow.





Sunday, March 29, 2015

Paragraph Structure Popcorn Project

Making the Abstract Accessible


Reading and writing will always be fun but challenging subjects to teach because they are more closely related to teaching children to think than they are teaching children actual content, unlike Social Studies or Science.

This becomes even more challenging when your students come from language poverty backgrounds or are struggling to find their way two different languages at a young age. 

Having learned to speak a second language later in life, I can relate to my students when they're asked to perform multiple cognitive tasks in a second language. For example, talking to someone in Spanish about my opinions about the weather or newest books or movies is easy. However, it's much harder for me to explain how to work a math problem as I'm doing it. If I've worked it already, my brain can then devote itself to processing the information out in the second language, but if I'm explaining it as I go, it's much more difficult because my brain is already using most of its available RAM (pardon the computing metaphor) to process the math.

Think about what this means for your ESL or low language learners.



Suppose you're a student grappling with spelling, recalling unfamiliar but potentially usually vocabulary, managing sloppy handwriting into something legible and thinking also about what you want to say and translating it in your head.

Now, add the cognitive process of having to see the abstract connections of information and grammatical structures of language to that.

See why it's so hard for them?

What seems implicit to the native speaker is only implicit because the meaning of what has been said is clearer than the words themselves. As long as the brain is occupied deciphering the symbols on the page it's too busy to see the meaning behind it, and therefore unable to see the connections.

How to Help


Explicit modeling helps the implicit become visible for ELL's. Help your students see what the connections are through modeling and activities that decrease erase the other cognitive processes so that they can focus on the connections you're wanting them to make. 

This is why I created the Popcorn Paragraph structure project. The paragraph is already written for the students in a way that gives them friendly manipulatives that allow for a margin of error and correction that lengthy writing and erasing does not. Your students minds will be free to concentrate on the meaning of what's being said and the relationships of the types of sentences they're working with rather than muddling down into the other cognitive processes that would keep them from learning to see relationships in meaning and structure.


YouTube Modeling




Ramon writes a paragraph explaining the types of sentences as he goes.  Click the picture above to see it!

Popcorn Project




You can preview the project itself here at my TPT store:



Monday, December 15, 2014

Character Traits Vocabulary: Key to Inferencing

Inferencing, the Behemoth of Reading Tests



Shoot at it all you want. No matter what you do it's coming. To quote Bill & Ted quoting Poison, "Every rose has its thorn," and if you haven't met realized how thorny inferencing can be, you haven't been teaching Reading in the United States for very long.

With the intention of increasing rigor, tests have become less about whether students can locate information in text and more about whether students can interpret what they read by connecting the information to background knowledge, other information in the text, or synonyms in their own vocabulary.

Inferencing is Godzilla.

To try to narrow this topic down about how to tackle this behemoth, I want to specifically examine inferencing in fiction.



Saturday, December 13, 2014

STAAR Spaghetti 'Strandards'

Why You Are Actually A Spaghetti Teacher


Planning for new Reading teachers can be like a giant bowl of spaghetti. Imagine that you, the teacher, are a meatball, freshly ground out of your university and seasoned and seared a little with some guided teaching experience. You finally find a bowl that will hire you on for that dream job: Reading! You love books more than anything, and you can't wait to impart that to your students, but first, you have to do something--you have to plan how to teach to them. What are you teaching them? This big confusing plate of spaghetti strandards:


The state tells you to teach the children this bowl of strandards (the TEKS, which is composed of SE's), but how do you do it? Where do you start? Unlike math, where everything stacks up like a building, reading skills are all interconnected and mixed together. Which way is up? Which way is down? Good, balanced literacy sauce holds it all together and flavors it, but at the end of the year, the state is going to rate your school's performance based on one thing:

the STAAR test.

Did your students eat all the spaghetti strandards or not? How well did they get it?

The guidance tool given to lead your little bowl is called the TEKS, which is a legal document accumulation of SE's (student expectations). You're familiar with them as little codes like 5.2B or 4.6A and they're all sub-categorized as Readiness Standards or Supporting Standards.

Your district will provide you with a scope and sequence of when to teach these standards, and some districts may even provide trainings where you 'analyze' the SE's (spaghetti strandards!) by having you make sentence diagrams and circle all the parts of speech in different colors to somehow convey the depth of meaning of the legal verbiage provided by the state. This might be beneficial to people who are not strong verbal thinkers, but most likely, if you're a Reading teacher, you're not one of those people and you understand the SE you read as you read the first time through.

So I want to challenge you to take your understanding deeper in a more effective way, a way that aligns how you think about the standard with how your school is rated for teaching it.

Comparing Reading SE's to STAAR



If you have been teaching for more than a year, you've seen the elephant. You know that your passion for imparting a love literacy isn't enough for success in the world of standardized testing (and if you do teach somewhere where this is not true, do let me know). The rest of us must be tactical. Pushing the bowl of spaghetti across the table isn't enough. We must be spaghetti generals, if I can be permitted to make this extended metaphor any sillier. 


I have created a chart (through many hours of blood, sweat and labor) that places each question stem from the last three years of released STAAR tests for 3rd, 4th and 5th grade alongside the SE that is tagged as testing. While it's nothing new for teachers to create question stem cards from the tests, I've not yet seen anyone compile them into one hulking monster for Reading Spaghetti Generals to slay.

Until now, that is. 



You can download the chart at my TPT website for free at:


Suggestions for Spaghetti Generals on How to Interpret the Chart


As a professional (and general) in the field of education, you can read the chart and draw as many conclusions as you wish. I suggest you consider the following:

  • How do what the questions ask on STAAR compare with the wording in the SE? 
  • Is my teaching of this skill including making my students think the way the test is asking them to think? 
  • What words show up most frequently in the stems for my grade level or 3-5?
  • Which SE's are tested most heavily? Why is that? 
  • Is the time I spend on any single SE widely disproportionate to how heavily its tested? (I know heat maps are popular right now, but if you've got a low percentile on text structures are you really getting the bang for your buck by targeting a skill that's rarely tested?)
  • When will you review this? At the beginning of each six weeks? At the beginning of each unit? With your team?

Sample Reflection


Good teachers model their thinking for their students, so I'll take my own figurative medicine here, and then bid you a fond farewell till next time.




When I used to read the SE above in blue, 5.10A, before having STAAR stems to compare it to, I was unsure of whether I was teaching 'drawing conclusions', 'author's purpose' or 'evaluating' the work itself and comparing it the intended purpose. It seems that the person who worded this statement meant something most similar to latter. It would have the students thinking at the second highest rung of Bloom's Taxonomy, but you can't really test that kind of thinking with colored bubbles.

So, when this skill is tested by STAAR what does it really mean? It means the second idea: author's purpose. The repeating idea in each of these particular stems is author's purpose.

The only repeating test vocabulary word I think my students might be uncomfortable with is 'selection,' so I'll be sure to put that in my vocabulary study and use it while teaching.

In the overall scheme of things, it's been tested five times, so it's likely to be tested, but not heavily. There are a lot of other nonfiction SE's competing with it. My students need to know it, but it's probably not going to destroy them if they're weak on it, unlike Figure 19D & E, 5.2B, or 5.6B.

Vertically, I notice that it hasn't yet been tested in third, tested once in 4th and primarily examined in 5th. I also notice that the intention of the SE for 4th correlates even less than the 5th grade version. Fourth grade teachers, beware. This is exactly why I made this chart--to show that knowing your SE's isn't enough during test season.

Disclaimer


Remember the spaghetti analogy from the beginning of this article? I want to remind you about the sauce. After reading through all the legalese and teacher verbiage here, you may be shaking your head and saying, "Tsk, tsk, she's telling me to teach to the test! I won't stop good literacy for this!"

I agree.

Don't ever forget the sauce (balanced literacy) and the dear faces of those for whom you were preparing the spaghetti anyway. The chart is only guide to inform you, to keep you from getting blindsided perhaps and accelerate your own understanding of an incredibly complicated matter: the teacher of reading.

I salute all of you.