Showing posts with label Metacognition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Metacognition. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 29, 2015

Inferencing

D: What is an inference?


  • An inference is a conclusion (idea) you make by connecting what you read to what you know.

P: How do I make an inference?

  1. I can retell what I read accurately.
  2. I connect what I read to what I know.

Do this: 

Not this:


And definitely not:


C: When/Why do I make inferences?

  • I make inferences during/after reading.
  • I make inferences because it brings me to a deeper understanding of the text. 


Sunday, September 27, 2015

The Big Data Derailment


Let me start this article off on the right foot:

I do like data.

I really do.

Not as much as a Triple Chocolate Andy's Frozen Custard, but I do like it. I sit around at home with cat and play with data for fun. (Frozen custard on the side would make it even better)

Now that I've admitted that I'm going to say something bold. Something that might make you curl your toes a little bit because it (along with some of my other views on literacy) go against the current of what's popular in testing, er, teaching these days.

Analyzing STAAR data is derailing literacy instruction in Texas.


Data Driven to Death


Data is good, but it's only good if you know how to read it, and the longer I watch trends of analysis the more I see data being completely misinterpreted all over. 

We're missing the forest for the trees, folks.

Like I mentioned in a previous article, Reading isn't like the other tests. Reading tests have two components: passages and questions.

If you're only analyzing the questions and using that to draw conclusions about quality of instruction, student ability, and overall literacy and direction of you or your school's direction, then you could be sending your train out the front window.

Why are so many schools struggling so much to catch up to current Reading standards and failing. There's a lot of reasons, because an entire state of people and schools is so vast and diverse, but I'd like to focus on just one aspect today: miscalculations.

Teachers and administrators are reading their SE hotspots correctly and even putting them into perspective by using blueprints and testing frequency charts. However, with this advent of testing culture and the need for everyone to be 'data driven' all the time, it has taught districts, schools, and teachers to think about literacy like this:


We study and study and study. We discuss and discuss and discuss. We plan and plan and plan. We do it all for the sake of being data driven! We want to fix those particular SE's! We must! We're doing it for our kids' sakes, our schools' sakes, our own sakes!

But it's not working.

If it were the real answer, for all the work we're putting in over four years worth of STAAR now, we ought to be seeing more results. Instead, more schools than ever are being classified by the state as "Improvement Required."

Why, oh, why?

Because, like I mentioned, we're missing the forest for the trees. Because of popular trends in educational jargon, we've focused on the tiles, the small pieces of what we think the problem is based on what a testing company paid by the state (and now fired by the state) told us our problem was.

But here's the thing.

The tiles aren't literacy. They're good for analysis to an extent, but they're not enough.

Why? Because literacy isn't tiles. It isn't isolated concepts or isolated skills. All those little things: character roles, conflict, main idea, inferencing, drawing conclusions, context clues--they all link up into what literacy actually is. If we want to improve, we have to zoom out to the big picture.

Literacy is a mosaic of cognitive skills. 



Those skills that the test doesn't open examine or quantify are what break our students if we don't address them in the classroom, even if we don't have numerical data from a test to quantify or justify their instruction. 

If you have a population of students who are not passing STAAR, don't only look at your SE's.

Also consider: 
  • Metacognition (Rigor): Can your students think about thinking?
  • Lexile/Guided Reading Levels: Can your students understand enough of the passage to have a chance of passing?
  • Do your students believe in themselves? Do they think they can be good readers?
  • Fluency: Do your students read fast enough to remember what they read?
  • Decoding: Hand in hand with fluency--Do your students need serious intervention?
  • Vocabulary: Do your students know what to do when they don't understand?
  • Background Knowledge: What are you doing to broaden the knowledge base of students whose families can't afford to take them places to gain new experiences?
  • Language Transition: What SIOP strategies are you using to help students find success in their second language?
  • Stamina: Are you giving your students time every day to read self-selected texts? Reading is a skill, not a content. You don't get better at doing it by learning about it.




Saturday, August 29, 2015

Favorite Fiction Mentor Texts

A mentor text is a book that a teacher uses repeatedly to illustrate different concepts. Already being familiar with the story itself means that students can focus on certain aspects of the story or reading strategies being applied to the story.

I'd like to share a few of my favorite mentor texts today for fifth grade appropriate fiction. These are all books that both I and my students love. According to my school librarian, I'm a "book snob" (I have standards!), so these are books that really had to impress me to make the cut as something I want to read and reread.

King Midas: Stewig/Rayyan


In fifth grade in Texas our special genre for our year is myths. Where fourth grade gets to introduce folktales and tall tales, fifth graders get to dip their toes into Greek/Roman and Norse mythologies for the first time in a school setting.

King Midas is a classic tale of king who loved gold too much, and this retelling of the story is a powerful one with a big dose of whimsy and humor. Fifth graders like details and the illustrations in this book tell the story so well that you can make inferences and draw conclusions just by inspecting all corners of the page with as much attention as if you were chasing down Waldo. 

The story provides many opportunities to talk about character traits and change. It also has heaps of foreshadowing if you look for the hidden pictures inside the pictures. 

The Selfish Giant: Oscar Wilde/Chris Beatrice


This story is a classic, and as much as I love "The Happy Prince", Wilde has a better narrative voice here and the 19th century world is easier for younger modern readers to understand than its other famous companion story. 

The story is amazing, and the illustrations by Beatrice are the most beautiful version I've ever seen in any store anywhere for this classic story. You can really dive into them and hunt out the meaning of the pictures to use practicing predictions and making connections. Beyond that, the symbolism at the end (spoiler: the giant dies) is very challenging and leave some students feeling a little confused though still intrigued. This is good. Some students will be ready to start understanding symbolism already, and others you can start down the path toward carving out those synaptic pathways in their brains. 

Also, it makes a good complement to King Midas because they share similar (though not equal) themes, and reading them both makes for an interesting compare/contrast discussion. 

The Summer My Father was Ten: Brisson


Last but not least, this book is a great example of realistic fiction. I like it because the kids make so many personal connections. Everyone's gotten carried away while playing and done something bad at some point in their childhood, and the lesson about forgiveness and friendship in this book is powerful and deep. 

The illustrations are also deep, just like my other favorite books, adding another layer to the story rather than just being pictures.

Students sometimes like to make the connection between the kids playing in Mr. Bellavista's garden to the children playing in the Selfish Giant's garden. Again, it's another book that really connects well for discussions when read in tandem with the others, even though they all represent different genres.


Finding the Books

While I happened to get two out of three of these books at a Half-Price books in Dallas, they're all available on Amazon in case you can't find them in your school or local library. They're worth owning. You won't regret. 

Saturday, August 22, 2015

Summarizing


D: What is summarizing?


  • Summarizing is retelling the most important parts of a story accurately.

P: How do I summarize fiction?

  • I put the right character with the right action in the right order.
  • I focus on the important events.
    • Important events are the events that are connected to the conflict closely.
  • Beginning, Middle, End
  • I use the Fiction 4Q.

[Cut and glue in 4Q foldable.]



C: When/Why do I summarize?

  • I summarize during and after reading.
  • I summarize because it helps me know if I understand and helps me remember the story.


[5.9 Reading/Comprehension of Text/Independent Reading. Students read independently for sustained periods of time and produce evidence of their reading. Students are expected to read independently for a sustained period of time and summarize or paraphrase what the reading was about, maintaining meaning and logical order (e.g., generate a reading log or journal; participate in book talks).  

5.8.A  sequence and summarize the plot's main events and explain their influence on future events;

Fig19.E (E) summarize and paraphrase texts in ways that maintain meaning and logical order within a text and across texts; and]

Imagery



Imagery is descriptive phrases that authors use to help me visualize better.

[Draw a T-Chart labeled "Examples" and "Nonexamples".]




Reread a mentor text together, and using guided release, sort out examples of phrases and sentences that are imagery and that are not imagery and discuss why they are or are not. Some imagery is stronger than others, so talk about it. There's enough gray area to spark some interesting thought and discussion. 



[Fig19.C monitor and adjust comprehension (e.g., using background knowledge, creating sensory images, rereading a portion aloud, generating questions); 

(8)  Reading/Comprehension of Literary Text/Sensory Language. Students understand, make inferences and draw conclusions about how an author's sensory language creates imagery in literary text and provide evidence from text to support their understanding. Students are expected to evaluate the impact of sensory details, imagery, and figurative language in literary text.]

Visualizing

'

D: What is visualizing?

  • Visualizing is making a movie in your mind while you read.

P: How do I visualize?

  1. I understand the vocabulary.
  2. I use my memories to imagine what I'm reading by phrase or by sentence.
  3. I update my visualization as I go.
  4. I pay attention to imagery.
[Glue handout here.]

Imagery is descriptive phrases that authors use to help me visualize better.


C: When/why do I visualize?

  • I visualize while I read.
  • I visualize because it helps me understand and it makes reading fun.



[Figure 19.C (C) monitor and adjust comprehension (e.g., using background knowledge, creating sensory images, rereading a portion aloud, generating questions);]

Fix Up Strategies

What do I do when I don't understand what I read?

  • Reread what I didn't understand.
  • Reading what came before.
  • Slow down.
  • Use context clues or dictionaries to solve new words.
  • Remind myself of what I already know.
  • Talk it out with a partner.
  • (Change books.)
  • Take a break.
  • Talk to the teacher.


{Figure 19.C monitor and adjust comprehension (e.g., using background knowledge, creating sensory images, rereading a portion aloud, generating questions);]

Checking Understanding


D: What is checking understanding?


[Glue in handout here]

  • Checking understanding means I know when I'm reading with my eyes and brain, not just with my eyes.

P: How do I check my understanding?

  • While reading I notice:
    • frustration
    • tired
    • slow
    • many unknown words
    • not visualizing
  • After reading:
    • cannot retell what I read

C: When/Why do I check my understanding?

  • I check my understanding during and after reading.
  • Checking understanding helps me make meaning.

[Figure 19.C (C) monitor and adjust comprehension (e.g., using background knowledge, creating sensory images, rereading a portion aloud, generating questions)]

Previewing Texts




D: What is previewing?

      • Previewing is gathering information before reading a text.

P: How do I preview?

      • For a Book:
        1. I read the whole title and think about it. I predict the genre.
        2. I examine (look carefully) the illustrations.
        3. I read the blurbs.
        4. I set a purpose for reading.
        5. I use the five finger rule.
      • Previewing on a Test
        1. I circle the title and think about it. I predict the genre using clues.
        2. I read the questions and circle 2 or 3 important words.
          • DO NOT READ THE ANSWER CHOICES!

C: Why/when do I preview?

      • I preview before reading. I preview because it helps me choose just-right books and make connections to my schema. This helps me understand what I'm reading better when I begin.

[Figure 19.A (A) establish purposes for reading selected texts based upon own or others’ desired outcome to enhance comprehension;]

Kinds of Knowing

Declarative Knowing:
      • What is the strategy?

Procedural Knowing:
      • How do I do the strategy?

Conditional Knowing:
      • When and why do I do the strategy?